Good news and bad news everyone. The good news is that today I get to rage/blog about my favorite topics: reproductive justice, the Christian right’s version of “religious freedom,” and (indirectly) knitting. The bad news is that Hobby Lobby filed a federal lawsuit against the “Obamacare” contraception mandate. As a knitter and reproductive justice activist who has, on occasion, spent more money on yarn than food in a week, this is really upsetting news for me. At least I’ve used their yarn to knit a cozy for my “whore pills” (as Jessie calls them) and for yarnbombing?

Anyway. The owners of Hobby Lobby, the Green family, believe that covering birth control and emergency contraception for their over 13,000 employees in 14 states violates their freedom of speech and freedom of religion.

Carly reacting to Hobby Lobby “losing their freedom”

LOLOLOLOLOL GOOD ONE GUYS

The lawsuit is justified by the Greens because their “religious beliefs forbid them from participating in, providing access to, paying for, training others to engage in, or otherwise supporting abortion-causing drugs and devices.” This situation would be hilarious if it weren’t actually true, given the fact that birth control pills and emergency contraception are not “abortion causing drugs.” Out of the 13,000 Hobby Lobby employees, I doubt all are Evangelical Christians like the Green family. I’m sure that many of them want or need access to contraceptives for a variety of equally valid reasons regardless of their faith, or lack thereof.

I feel like I am constantly having to say this in other posts I’ve written, but apparently it needs to be said again. Christians are not being oppressed just because they aren’t allowed to force everyone around them to live by the same rules they do through legislation.

Being unable to deny your employees access to vital reproductive health care is NOT restricting your religious freedom or freedom of speech. Hobby Lobby is an Evangelical Christian organization based out of Oklahoma. They are the majority. In a country that has an establishment clause in its constitution to prevent theocracy. Hobby Lobby employees shouldn’t have to choose between healthcare and employment, and NO ONE should have to live by Christian theology if they don’t want to.

Green family, you don’t have to worry about being attacked because you aren’t a Christian. You don’t know what it’s like to have your home vandalized for not being Christian, to be afraid to disclose your upbringing with a new acquaintance for fear of conversion attempts, alienation, or worse, violence. And not everyone has the class privilege to “just work somewhere else” if they can’t afford their prescriptions and their employer refuses to cover them in their insurance plan. Comparing insurance coverage to these examples of religious oppression is just sickening. You have no idea what having your religious freedom violated feels like. You don’t get to use your religion as a free pass to do whatever you want.

Carly has a crush on Dana Scully and loves cartoons, if you couldn’t already tell. She really wishes there was an ethical way for her to access affordable yarn, because dammit if Hobby Lobby is getting any more of her money.

Tagged with:
 
  • A Dart

    Shop at Michael’s!  I’m having the same issue with cognitive dissonance.  I have an Etsy shop, so I need Hobby Lobby.  =(

  • Poetryline

    A non-religious amen!

  • Melissa Wass72

    As a licensed Minister and a student of theology, I do not support the Green family. During this whole controversy, Hobby Lobby has been fazing out Caron yarn (a somewhat ethically made American yarn) for their own version–which is made under undisclosed conditions in Turkey. Most of their decorative items are made in China under equally undisclosed conditions. Yet, they claim to run their business by “Christian” principles. Additionally, they are protesting a type of health care. Employees have the right to refuse the day after pill or use another type of birth control. Still, the Greens claim that for those who do access this type of medicine, they would be fianacing abortions. What? It’s like giving your employees vacation pay and then stipulating what they are allowed to do on that vacation or where they can go.  This kind of poor theology is a direct result of business majors attempting to theologize when they simply do not have the training.